Although most WordPress security plugins provide excellent security, they all follow a slightly different approach to provide protection.
There is no ‘best’ or ‘bad’ plugin; the right WordPress security plugin depends on what you are looking for.
WordPress website security is the most crucial aspect of your site; you must ensure that the plugin you pick comes with all the necessary features to keep your site safe and secure.
To help clarify your search, we have compared Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare with the critical security parameters.
At the end of this article, we’ll give you our recommendation, so stick around till the end to find which security plugin we think is worth your investment.
Without further ado, let us see which plugin is the best security plugin.
Sucuri vs Wordfence vs MalCare: Basic Overview
Sucuri, Wordfence, and MalCare are exceptional plugins out of thousands that protects your site from various risks and threats.
But before we dive into our in-depth comparison of Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare, we’ll give a quick introduction to each and provide a basic overview of Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare.
Sucuri is one of the most popular security plugins that gives exceptional security features to ensure peace of mind. The cloud-based platform protects your WordPress site from threats and cleans up your site whenever it faces any vulnerabilities.
The plugin monitors your site and immediately notifies you before any events happen. Sucuri also plays a crucial role in enhancing your site’s performance by including caching, data center load balancing, and more.
When you upgrade to the premium plans, it also adds an extra layer of security by providing SSL.
Related Read: How to Recover a Hacked WordPress Website
Wordfence is a freemium plugin that comes with a malware scanner and an endpoint firewall.
The plugin also comes with other security features to secure your site from all the potential risks and threats, including Brute force attacks to ensure a smooth workflow of your WordPress site.
It regularly scans your website and includes blocking all the known IP hackers for maximum security. Wordfence also monitors regular user activities and prevents legitimate users from being locked out.
MalCare is one of the premium security plugins that secure your WordPress site with its excellent security features. With over 400,000 users, it continues to protect thousands of websites globally.
MalCare provides one-click malware removal and scanning to ensure the utmost safety and gives a stress-free website experience.
This security plugin ensures complete security to protect from various malware infections. Additionally, the plugin comes with an easy to use interface and easy installation.
Wordfence vs Sucuri vs MalCare: Critical Features
All three plugins come with exceptional features. Listing all the features is impossible as the list would be never-ending. But let’s go through some of the key features of these security plugins.
Sucuri Key Features
- Sucuri takes care of the speed of your site. The plugin delivers a blazing-fast performance with its highly optimized CDN.
- The plugin removes any malicious codes in your files and ultimately secures your site.
- Sine SEO spam keywords injections that harm your site. Sucuri removes SEO spam.
- The plugin prevents future attacks from the website firewall application by blocking attacks through filtering malicious traffic. By filtering malicious traffic, Sucuri ensures that hacks are prevented and speed up your site.
- The security plugin removes blacklist status by submitting a blacklist removal request on your behalf.
- Sucuri provides reliable customer support. You get 24/7 customer support from its professional team.
- Sucuri continually monitors your website, whether it being attacked by threats or not. If your site receives any suspicious threats, the plugin immediately notifies you.
- To add extra layers of security, Sucuri comes with an SSL certificate on the higher-tier plans.
Wordfence Key Features
- Wordfence comes with an endpoint firewall, which provides better protection than the cloud. With an endpoint firewall, you get extra security compared to cloud firewalls.
- Wordfence comes with a security scanner that scans your website thoroughly and detects any suspicious threats and risks.
- The plugin comes with an intuitive way to manage all your sites in one place, known as Wordfence central. It gives you easier access and more power to control your sites in one place.
- Wordfence comes with leaked password protection to protect your site against passwords stolen in data breaches.
- With the live traffic feature, you can monitor visits and hack attempts, including the time of day a user visits and the IP address.
- You get advanced manual blocking quickly and efficiently. You can manually block suspicious IP addresses, humans, or bots.
- With Wordfence, you can block brute force attacks permanently by using two-factor authentication.
- Wordfence also lets you block countries that are heavily known for malicious activities for added protection.
MalCare Key Features
- MalCare scans your website on its servers, which means there is no load on your server. With MalCare, your site will never slow down.
- MalCare comes with automated malware scanner removal, which fixes hacks in less than 60 seconds.
- MalCare comes with a smart scanner that gives protection from all the latest threats with its smart firewall.
- Unlike other security plugins that delete the entire files, MalCare removes the malware without breaking your website.
- MalCare comes with an intuitive dashboard that lets you manage multiple sites with ease.
- MalCare provides an in-built Captcha-based smart login protection that protects from bots trying to enter your website.
- Besides security, the plugin also lets you give your clients a detailed report by providing a proper insight to grow their business.
Wordfence vs Sucuri vs MalCare: Ease of Use & Getting Started
No matter how experienced you are, Ease of use is so important when considering any security plugin. The easier the process, the more time you save.
Even the most experienced developers look for plugins that come with a quick setup and easy management for your WordPress site.
Sucuri WordPress Security Plugin Ease of Use
Setting up Sucuri is straightforward and quick. To get started, all you need to do is install the plugin and head to the security tab in your WordPress dashboard. Once you click on the tab and see the results, you can configure the settings easily.
You can promptly see the state of your site on the sidebar. When you go with the premium version, you can create an account and name your domain to Sucuri’s. Although it involves some technical steps, you can get started without any hassle.
If you are managing multiple websites, the professional plan of Sucuri will benefit you a lot. Additionally, managing your website is easy, and it comes with an intuitive and simple interface.
Wordfence WordPress Security Plugin Ease of Use
Wordfence also provides easy startup. All you need to do is install the plugin and enter your email address to receive all the security alerts.
You can then access the Wordfence tab from your WordPress dashboard. Once there, Wordfence introduces a setup wizard that guides you through all the plugin’s essential features.
The dashboard does an excellent job of telling you how to get started and what to do. As you go further, you will see various guides about all the prominent features. You can then configure the important functionalities quickly.
One of the main reasons we like Wordfence is its more straightforward interface and has an excellent dashboard. The dashboard makes you feel at home and guides you through to have an efficient workflow without wasting your time.
MalCare WordPress Plugin Ease of Use
MalCare isn’t far behind when it comes to providing easy setup and management to its users. Like Sucuri and Wordfence, all you have to do is install the MalCare plugin and enter your email address.
Once done, the syncing process starts with the MalCare cloud dashboard. You can manage everything from MalCare’s cloud dashboard rather than the WordPress dashboard.
The premium version grants you access to additional features in your dashboard. Additionally, if you manage various sites at once, MalCare allows you to manage everything in one account.
Using the MalCare cloud dashboard makes managing multiple sites significantly more efficient.
Wordfence vs Sucuri vs MalCare: Website Application Firewall
Web Application Firewall (WAF) is vital when picking a security plugin as it filters requests before the user hits your site to provide extra security. This wall protects your site from all the suspicious IP addresses entering your site.
Fortunately, all these plugins come with WAF. However, you must ensure that the plugin is updated regularly for these plugins to work correctly.
Sucuri Security Plugin – Website Application Firewall
Sucuri’s firewall feature works tremendously well to protect your WordPress website by filtering traffic before allowing them to enter your WordPress website. It also protects you from zero-day exploits.
Because of this feature, your WordPress site runs lightning-fast, and you get the fastest page loading times through the CDN network.
This WordPress security plugin combines CDN and firewall and is known for its excellent firewall protection compared to the other plugins on the list.
Wordfence WordPress Security Plugin – Website Application Firewall
Wordfence provides firewall protection in both the free version and paid versions. It protects you from WordPress-specific attacks and general attacks.
Additionally, this WordPress security plugin is regularly updated to new firewall rules to protect from the new attacks.
The premium version gives you updates instantly; with the free version, you will get delayed with the updates. The premium version grants more protection to your WordPress site with its firewall protection.
MalCare Security Plugin – Web Application Firewall
MalCare says that it comes with a web application firewall; however, it is less effective than Sucuri and Wordfence. MalCare protects by blocking suspicious IP addresses, which is a useful feature.
Yet, the firewall is not updated regularly, which may cause a problem if you want to be fully updated with the latest versions.
Sucuri vs Wordfence vs Malcare: Malware Detection
Malware scanning and malware removal requests are critical for any website. Your plugin must come with a malware scanner that allows you to scan for malware quickly to maintain a clean WordPress website.
All three of these plugins provide malware scanning but in different ways.
Sucuri Firewall Malware Detection
Sucuri offers excellent malware scanning. Even with the free version, you can run malware scans and monitor your files’ integrity through the free site SiteCheck tool.
However, if you’re using the free version, you can only check the front-end files of your website. Due to this, Sucuri won’t find all the malware, and therefore, you cannot totally rely on the free version.
However, when you upgrade to the premium version, Sucuri takes malware scanning to the next level. With its server-side malware scanning, Sucuri analyzes all the threats that might not be visible through the front-end files.
Therefore, with the paid version, you get excellent malware scanning.
Wordfence Malware Detection
Wordfence allows you to run malware scans from your WordPress dashboard. In your WordPress dashboard, all you need to do is click on the Start New Scan option, and the plugin starts malware scanning on your server.
Besides the malware scanning, Wordfence also checks whether your plugins are outdated or if your passwords are weak.
The free version also lets you scan malware. However, the main difference between the free and paid version is the updates. The free version’s malware scan updates are delayed by a month, while with the paid version, you get updated regularly.
MalCare Malware Detection
The primary feature of MalCare is malware scanning, which means that the plugins’ focus is on scanning your site.
Unlike other plugins, MalCare runs scans and copies your files to off-site locations and then scans them instead of running scans using your resources. With the free version, malware scanning is limited.
However, when you upgrade to the premium version, you get one-click malware removal. Which means you can remove the detected malware with a single click.
This feature is incredible in that it saves you time and brings you the best malware scanning options.
Sucuri vs Wordfence vs MalCare: Security Hardening (Web Security)
Security hardening is nothing but the tweaks that you can make to secure your WordPress site more. Let’s have a quick look at the security hardening features of Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare.
Sucuri Security Pluign
Sucuri comes with an in-built hardening option area that allows you to make all the primary changes.
There are plenty of hardening options such as website firewall protection, blocking specific PHP files, information leakage, plugin and theme editor, and more.
Wordfence Security Plugin
Unlike Sucuri, Wordfence hardening rules come into other categories such as firewall and login protection.
However, Wordfence still comes with some basic security hardening principles like hiding your WordPress version and disabling code execution in the uploads directory.
MalCare Security Pluign
MalCare beats all the other security plugins when it comes to security hardening. The plugin divides security hardening into three categories – Essential, advanced, and paranoid.
The essential option comes with blocking PHP execution and disabling file editing. Advanced options include blocking plugins or theme installation.
Contrast that with the paranoid feature, which provides for changing security keys and resetting all your passwords. You can easily see all the options visible on your screen and further take action according to your needs.
Wordfence vs Sucuri vs MalCare: Support
Support is crucial, especially if you are not tech-savvy or a developer. Having good support by your side to guide you from setup to management is essential.
These security plugins come with various advanced features where you can stumble if you lack experience.
Without good customer support, finding the right solution can be time-consuming and draining. Luckily, all three plugins come with good customer support.
Sucuri Security Support
Sucuri comes with excellent customer support. The customer support is 24/7, so you can count on them for professional help. You can chat with the experts who respond immediately.
You can also contact the team through email, submit a ticket, or directly call customer support for a more personalized experience.
The knowledgebase of Sucuri also contains all the essential articles that can help you solve common issues. Moreover, you can also refer to the FAQs on the official website.
You can count on Wordfence to get reliable and professional help. The official website comes with many helpful resources. You can also get help through forums.
Additionally, when you upgrade to the premium version, you get priority support through a support ticket. And the documentation section consists of extensive documentation to help you troubleshoot.
And if that doesn’t work, there are additional resources available on the internet, which you can go through to get your help.
MalCare also comes with excellent customer support. The team behind MalCare is always there to assist you. They will provide solutions to your questions, irrespective of the size.
As soon as you land on the homepage of Wordfence, you can see the LiveChat popup. You can solve your issues immediately through the live chat.
The knowledgebase of Wordfence also comes with helpful articles and documents that will help you get through basic issues. Additionally, you can also submit a ticket for more personalized support.
Wordfence vs Sucuri vs MalCare: Price Comparison
Finally, we’ve come to the pricing comparison between Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare. Pricing is one of the most critical aspects of a security plugin because of how important security is to running a successful online business.
As a website owner, there are various investments you need to focus on, with security at the top of the list.
Therefore, make sure to pick the security plugin that fits your pocketbook and provides excellent value for your money. With that, let us have a look at the pricing of all the security plugins.
Sucuri WordPress Security Plugin Pricing
Sucuri comes with three pricing plans, which are:
- Basic – $199.99 per year.
- Pro – $299.99 per year.
- Plus – $499.99 per year.
All the plans come with malware removal and hack cleanup, virtual patching/hardening, CDN performance, DDoS mitigation, excellent customer support, and more.
However, an SSL certificate is not included in the basic plan. Additionally, the Malware & Hack Scan frequency also varies depending on the plan you choose.
Wordfence WordPress Security Plugin Pricing
The core plugin is free for everyone. However, the free version does not provide all the features, and you might miss out on some crucial security features. So if you choose Wordfence, we recommend picking the premium version.
Unlike Sucuri, Wordfence does not come with dedicated plans. The more licenses you purchase for Wordfence, the more you save. For example, if you buy one license, the pricing states at $99 per year. For 2-4 licenses, the pricing starts at $89.10. As you can see, the price decreases as the number of licenses increases. The premium plugin comes with excellent priority support and additional features. If you are willing to use Wordfence long-term, you can save more with a higher number of licenses.
MalCare WordPress Security Plugin Pricing
MalCare comes with three premium versions that fit the needs of various users. The three plans are:
- Personal: The plan is suitable for personal WordPress sites or one website. Priced at $99 per year, the personal plan comes with all the essential features to start on your blog or site.
- Small Business: The plan is ideal for small businesses and is priced at $259 per year. The Small Business plan comes with excellent security features and personalized support.
- Developer: The plan is best for developers or large WordPress websites with considerable traffic. The Developer plan is priced at $599 per year and supports up to 20 sites.
MalCare also provides a custom plan if you own a large website and need a personalized solution. You can get in touch with customer support to get a custom quote and add features according to your requirements.
Final Thoughts: The Best WordPress Security Plugin?
Sucuri, Wordfence, MalCare are all excellent choices. They are some of the best WordPress security plugins available and provide all the essential features that your WordPress site needs to keep threats at bay.
However, choosing between them is confusing because they are similar and provide exceptional features.
There is no ‘best’ plugin. The best WordPress security plugin depends on your needs and your budget. If you need an ultimate solution for your WordPress site, we recommend picking Sucuri.
And if you want security without spending a lot of money on a security plugin, you can choose Wordfence as the free version of Wordfence offers plenty of excellent features.
Finally, if you want an ultimate scanner that protects your database and files, MalCare should be your top pick. Our pick and the overall winner is Sucuri.
We suggest going with Sucuri as it comes with outstanding security features and it’s easy to use, so you can enjoy a safe website and focus on your business’s growth.
We hope you understand the differences between the three top plugins and find the right pick for you with our Sucuri vs. Wordfence vs. MalCare comparison.
If there’s still any confusion, do not hesitate to drop a comment in the comment section below.
More WordPress Plugin Articles:
- WPForms vs Gravity Forms vs Ninja Forms
- Best WordPress Security Plugins
- Best WordPress SEO Plugins
- Best WordPress Menu Plugins
- Best WordPress Backup Plugins
- Best WordPress Page Builder Plugins
- Best Contact Form Plugins for WordPress
- Best Genesis Framework Plugins
- Best WordPress Popup Plugins
- Best WordPress Countdown Plugins
- Best Image Optimizer Plugins
- Best WordPress Caching Plugins